Thursday, November 02, 2006

Kellie Pickler: Small Town Girl - The Album Review You Had to Know I'd Do

If you've kept up with this site for the past year, you'll know that Kellie Pickler and I have sort of a history. It was a bad start. I was at the forefront of the Kellie-haters, calling her Icky Picky and screaming "Kick Pickler" to the top of my lungs.

And then she did it. I don't know quite how, but she used her little vixen magic. Despite all my harsh words, I finally picked Pickler. My public apology to her and her subsequent response are all a matter of record now.

However, I've reserved the last measure of judgment for the release of her new album. No matter how much I like Kellie personally, she is still going to have to prove something with her album. She is going to have to be good.

She's not good.

She's GREAT.

I've been enjoying her recent single "Red High Heels" quite a bit recently. It has been featured prominently on my weekly show on Idol Waves Radio and has been quite popular. (If you want to catch her single on the show, it airs at 3 a.m., 10:30 a.m., 2:30 p.m. and 7:30 p.m. Central Standard Time each Tuesday. Her song was up to number 8 on the countdown this past week.) It's catchy, sassy, and just an overall good song. But could the rest of her album be any good?

You better believe it. She's a power-packed little ball of energy, our Kellie. No wonder then that 19 Entertainment chose to break with tradition this year and release her CD before the winner's CD release. (Typically, non-winners are contractually bound to hold off on releasing an album until the first and second place winners are on the market.) Kellie's is the first official 19 release this year. (Ayla Brown is the first actual release, but she's not in the 19 stable.)

For this review, I used the tried-and-true car stereo test. I had to keep driving a while, because once I got started there was no way I was leaving the car till the CD was over.

It would be easy to imagine Kellie coming out and doing a sort of Clay Aiken-esque disc, with watered-down country ballads and generic cover songs, but Small Town Girl is full of energy, and Kellie herself comes at you like a spitfire, railing on the irresponsible men in her life, celebrating her countryfied persona, and basically getting you on the dance floor for a good old fashioned hootenanny. For a girl who doesn't know the meaning of the word "ballsy," she most certainly is.

For me, the biggest moments on the whole album come smack dab in the middle, on the track "I Wonder." Kellie's tear-jerking ode to her absentee mother is quite a punch in the gut that left me wiping an un-masculine bit of moisture out of my eye. You can hear the hurt in her voice, and she perhaps has never put more heart and soul into any performance than she does in this song. If this isn't released as a single, then someone needs to be fired.

Even though this is the most powerful track on the album, the rest are no slouch jobs either. She ranges from being almost snarky on "Things That Never Cross a Man's Mind," to bleeding out some heartbreak on "Didn't You Know," to breathing nostalgia on "Small Town Girl," to having fun on "One of The Guys," and then back to being sentimental on "My Angel," a tribute to her grandmother. And I still love "Red High Heels."

In fact, I just love me some Kellie Pickler.

"But J.D., what about that nasal voice you kept harping on during Idol??" you ask. Well, to be honest, it's still there, but not as much, because she's obviously been doing work on her vocals. But I think a lot of what makes her voice sound thin is the fact that she's a fairly high soprano voice anyway. The truth is that once you listen to the album, you'll realize that even though she does go into head voice sometimes, she always has complete vocal control. (And honestly, whatever else is left is easily handled by the back-up singers.) Still, in her proper element, any shortcomings she might have just melt away. And she's loads better than she ever was on any of the Idol shows.

Long story short, go get this album. You can pick it up for the low low cost of $9.99 at Best Buy for a limited time, or you can click here to order it from Amazon. It's well worth owning.


At 9:48 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thank you so much for giving Kellie a great review, J.D.! She definitely deserves all of the positive media attention she's been getting lately after all the crap she went through on idol. This album proves she has strong vocals and a strong personality.

I'll always be picking Pickler! <3

Kellie Bean 208

At 11:53 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I really like kellie but I dont think her album will do the sales to keep her on the record label for another album...i dont see her sophmore release doing anygood at all

At 12:04 AM, Blogger J.D. said...

Well, if we're to judge by the initial chart performance of "Red High Heels," then Miss Pickler could be sitting pretty. That song exploded onto the country music charts and is being picked up left and right. You really can't tell at this moment how things will do, but with the 19 machine behind her and the incredible momentum she has had going into this, she's a can't miss. She's going to slide right into Carrie's demographic with little to no problem. And if her second single plays well, you can go ahead and clear a spot on your shelf for CD #2.

I seem to recall people saying similar things about Josh Gracin, and look at him now.

At 8:12 AM, Blogger Rosier - Brazil - JROCK and JPOP said...

great review JD
Kellie album is really amazing

At 1:59 PM, Blogger Michael said...


Great review of Kellie Pickler's first album. Ahhhh, the things we said and the way she was treated during the Idol season in most all the blogs.


Post a Comment

<< Home